The Commons: A Fishing Game About the Tragedy of the Commons

The Commons in Season 1, Year 1 of 10. Lake Millbrook is full of fish at 96% Fish Population with 960 Fish Remaining. The Total Earnings board lists Old Murray, Mr. D, The Kowalski Brothers, and The Reyes Brothers.

Tragedy of the commons is easy to define and hard to feel. So I made it a fishing game.

The Commons in Season 6. The lake is down to 32% with 317 fish left. The earnings board shows the Kowalski Brothers in the lead, and the turn box warns Fish are getting scarce while asking how many boats to send out, from 1 to 5.

Students fish Lake Millbrook for ten years alongside three computer fishers. Each season they choose how many boats to send out, from one to five. More boats means more gold right now. The fish grow back, but only if enough are left in the lake.

The Commons collapse screen: THE LAKE IS EMPTY. The fish are gone. Each of you watched the others and thought: If I don't take it, they will. You were all right. And now you're all done.

On my own test run I tried to keep up with the Kowalski Brothers and sent five boats almost every season. By year six the lake was down to 32%. In year ten it was empty.

The Commons final screen, The Lake Is Dead. Final earnings rank The Kowalski Brothers first and Mr. D second. Lake Millbrook final state is 0%, with the line Everyone was rational. Everyone had reasons.

I finished second in gold, and nobody had a lake left to fish. The final screen says it best: "Everyone was rational. Everyone had reasons." That is the conversation I want my Economics students to have.

Play free: https://games.theaiteacherlab.com

Want to help your teachers save time with AI? Book a PD session for your school.

New ideas every week: Follow The AI Teacher Lab on Facebook.